Your Cy Young winners

[Rosco]

Tim Lincecum is having a hell of a year. He would be my NL Cy Young winner if the season ended right now. For the AL ... I'd go with Zack Greinke. It might have been Halladay a month ago - but he's been pitching terribly since the all-star break.

[David]

Chris Carpenter is going to lock up the NL Cy Young with the way he's been pitching the past few months.